Island Escapes: Dreamy North American Islands You’ve Never Heard Of

13 August 2025

Let’s face it—when you think of island getaways, your mind probably drifts to the Caribbean or the Maldives. But what if I told you that right here in North America, there are hidden gems waiting to sweep you off your feet? That’s right, folks. Whether you’re craving serene beaches, lush forests, or quirky local charm, these dreamy North American islands have got it all. And the best part? You’ve probably never heard of them.

Pack your sunscreen, grab your flip-flops, and let’s take a closer look at some jaw-dropping island escapes you’ll want to add to your travel bucket list.

1. Vancouver Island, Canada

You’ve likely heard of Vancouver, the bustling city in British Columbia. But have you heard about Vancouver Island? Nestled just off Canada’s west coast, this island is hands-down one of the most underrated spots in North America. It’s like the Pacific Northwest got a glow-up.

Why Visit?

Imagine rugged coastlines, misty rainforests, and cozy little towns that feel like they belong in a Hallmark movie. Vancouver Island is a haven for outdoor enthusiasts—hiking, kayaking, and whale watching are all on the menu here. Pro tip: head to Tofino, the laid-back surf town where the vibe is as chill as the ocean breeze.

Love wildlife? This island is home to bears, bald eagles, and even orcas. It’s like a real-life nature documentary.

2. Isla Espíritu Santo, Mexico

Okay, so you know Mexico has gorgeous beaches. But skip Cancun’s crowds and take a boat ride to Isla Espíritu Santo in the Sea of Cortez. This unspoiled paradise is practically a love letter to nature lovers.

What Makes It Special?

This island isn’t just pretty—it’s protected. Isla Espíritu Santo is a UNESCO Biosphere Reserve, meaning it’s teeming with crystal-clear waters, coral reefs, and unique wildlife. Want to swim with sea lions? You can do that here. Feeling more adventurous? Try snorkeling and meet tropical fish that look like they’ve swum straight out of Finding Nemo.

Here’s the thing about Espíritu Santo: it’s the kind of place where you can ditch the chaos of modern life. No Wi-Fi, no distractions—just pure, unfiltered bliss.

3. Mackinac Island, Michigan, USA

Ever wish you could step back in time? Mackinac Island makes that daydream a reality. Located in Lake Huron, this island is a throwback to a simpler era—think horse-drawn carriages, fudge shops, and Victorian architecture.

Why It’s Worth a Visit

Cars are banned on the island, which means you’ll get around by bike, foot, or a charming horse-drawn carriage. Pretty romantic, right? The island is small but mighty, offering everything from cozy inns to historic forts.

And the cherry on top? Mackinac is a fudge paradise. I’m not exaggerating when I say their fudge alone is worth the trip. It’s the kind of place where you’ll want to slow down and savor the moment—along with a sweet treat or three.

4. Amelia Island, Florida, USA

Think all of Florida is about theme parks and spring breakers? Think again. Tucked away in the northeastern corner of the state, Amelia Island is like Florida’s classy cousin—elegant, peaceful, and absolutely stunning.

What Sets It Apart?

This laid-back getaway is famous for its pristine beaches, charming downtown area, and Spanish moss-draped oak trees (hello, Instagram-worthy photos!). Whether you want to relax by the sea or explore its Victorian-era history, Amelia Island caters to every kind of traveler.

Don’t leave without trying the local seafood. Trust me, the shrimp and grits here will knock your flip-flops off.

5. Fogo Island, Canada

If you’ve got a soft spot for quirky, off-the-beaten-path destinations, say hello to Fogo Island. Found off Newfoundland’s northeastern coast, this charming island is a world of its own.

The Vibe

Fogo Island is the kind of place where you can disconnect from the world and reconnect with yourself. It’s remote (like, REALLY remote) and wild in the most beautiful way. Picture rugged cliffs, colorful fishing villages, and an unshakeable sense of tranquility.

What’s cool about Fogo is how it blends old-world charm with modern luxury. The Fogo Island Inn (Google it—it’s insane) is a high-end hotel that’s all about sustainable tourism. It’s posh yet cozy, like curling up under a designer blanket.

6. Santa Cruz Island, California, USA

You’ve heard of Catalina Island, but did you know Santa Cruz Island is part of the Channel Islands National Park? It’s like California’s best-kept secret.

Why Go?

This island is an adventurer’s dream. Think sea caves, dramatic cliffs, and hiking trails that wind through breathtaking landscapes. And get this—the island is home to animals you won’t find anywhere else, like the Santa Cruz Island fox. Nature nerds, rejoice!

Kayaking through the sea caves is an absolute must. It’s equal parts thrilling and awe-inspiring, like stepping into a scene from a National Geographic cover.

7. Shelter Island, New York, USA

Forget the Hamptons. Shelter Island is where you go for a low-key escape from the hustle and bustle of New York City. Just a ferry ride away, this island oozes charm without the pretentiousness.

What’s the Appeal?

Life here moves at a slower pace, and honestly, that’s its biggest draw. Spend your days biking along quiet roads, exploring nature preserves, or simply lounging by the water. Sunset Beach is a fan favorite for its dreamy views and lively atmosphere.

It’s the perfect weekend getaway. Whether you’re sipping cocktails at a trendy beachfront bar or soaking up the island's serene vibe, Shelter Island delivers big-time relaxation.

8. Cumberland Island, Georgia, USA

Looking for an island with a touch of mystery? Cumberland Island is your spot. Georgia’s largest and southernmost barrier island is a treasure trove of history, nature, and untamed beauty.

What’s So Cool About It?

Cumberland Island feels like stepping into another world. Wild horses roam the beaches, moss-covered ruins whisper secrets of the past, and ancient oak trees create a canopy straight out of a fairy tale.

Want to go camping? This is one of the best places to do it. Imagine falling asleep under a starry sky with the sound of waves crashing in the background. If that doesn’t sound dreamy, I don’t know what does.

9. Sable Island, Canada

Sable Island might just be the most mysterious island on this list. Located off the coast of Nova Scotia, it’s often referred to as the “Graveyard of the Atlantic” due to its shipwreck history. But don’t let that scare you away—this island is a beacon of raw, untamed beauty.

Why It’s Worth the Journey

Known for its wild horses and endless dunes, Sable Island feels like a mythical place brought to life. It’s remote, rugged, and undeniably unique. Surrounded by the Atlantic Ocean, it’s a sanctuary for wildlife, including seals and rare bird species.

Getting here isn’t easy, but for adventurous souls looking for an unforgettable experience, it’s absolutely worth the trip.

Wrap-Up: Your Next Island Escape Awaits

There you have it—nine dreamy North American islands that deserve to be on your radar. Whether you’re craving adventure, tranquility, or a little bit of both, these islands offer something for everyone.

So, which one are you adding to your travel plans? Don’t overthink it—sometimes, the most memorable trips are to places you never expected. Grab your beach bag and start exploring. Life's too short to stick to the mainland, right?